I’m not ashamed of my love for all things pumpkin and spice and everything nice. Not one bit. So I combined my favorite fall dessert flavor and my favorite dessert to make the ultimate. Pumpkin chai spiced whoopie pies.
I fell in love with whoopie pies in the fourth grade on a trip to Pennsylvania Dutch country. It seemed pretty smart to me that they would basically make a cake eatable with your hands, instead of requiring a proper dish and silverware.
I can taste my first one now. As cheesy as it sounds, it’s absolutely true. It was a perfectly baked, moist, delectable two rounds of cake with a beautifully fluffy creme in the middle that wasn’t too sweet and complimented the cake perfectly.
The girls operating the farm stand where we bought them were dressed traditional PA dutch, one older, one younger, and then a toddler. All bare foot. In fact, I remember the feet of the toddler because she clearly had an infected toe, due to an ingrown toenail (only my ballerina self would realize that was the problem) and didn’t seem to mind one bit. Maybe not the most picturesque memory, but a memory nonetheless.
Only a few weeks after getting home from our trip I grabbed one of the cookbooks I bought while in Lancaster county and made a whole spread for me and my childhood best friend that included whoopie pies for dessert. I formulated this recipe later on in life and recently made it for a group of my husbands friends who all came over for a fall party we hosted.
3C All purpose gf flour (I used Bob’s Red Mill one to one, you can probably get away using the gluten free flour you like, but I don’t suggest using anything super out there like paleo flour….just don’t)
1T Ground Cinnamon
2t Pumpkin Pie Spice
2t Ground Ginger
1t Nutmeg, fresh grated preferably
1t Ground Clove
1t Baking Soda
1t Baking Powder
1C Brown Sugar
1C Granulated Sugar
1C Organic Palm Shortening (you can get some here)
1 Can Pumpkin Puree (not pumpkin pie mix)
Preheat oven to 350
Combine dry ingredients and set aside
Combine Sugars and palm shortening, mix with a hand or stand mixer
Mix in egg and vanilla, just till combined
Slowly mix the dry ingredients with the wet by hand, or in your stand mixer
Once the batter has come together, allow it to sit for rougly 30 minutes or until you’re ready to pipe out your individual whoopie pie rounds. If you don’t want your mix to be typical gluten free grainy, don’t skip this step. It helps any gf baking tremendously.
Line a baking sheet with parchment paper or a sil pat.
Pipe out each individual cake round, roughly 3” in diameter. You can use a piping bag or a ziploc bag with one of the corner tips cut off — I prefer this because it gets messy and can be thrown away. Easy clean up!
** The batter is THICK ** This is why I recommend only piping out 3’ diameter cake round at first. Once you do that, oil your hand with coconut oil or butter, you’re choice. Using your oiled hands spread each piped cake round out 2 ish more inches in diameter by pressing down and out making sure the piped batter comes together. This step makes them flatter. Otherwise, because of the batters thickness, they would be obnoxiously tall. This is why I recommend only piping out about 3” cakes, if you piped out the full size they would be way to big to handle. Not that I’ve done that. Learn from my mistakes lol
Once you have all your cake round spread out, pop into your preheated oven for 10 minutes or until they’re cooked through and slightly firm.
Set them aside to cool on a cookie rack and make the chai spiced creme filling
Chai Spiced Creme Filling Ingredients:
1C Organic Palm Shortening
3C Powdered Sugar
1/2t Ground Black Pepper
Beat the shortening, vanilla, and spices together until combined
Add the powdered sugar slowly until all combined.
With a piping bag of choice half full with your chai spiced creme filling, pipe a decent sized swirl onto one pumpkin cake round
Top with another cake round and press until the creme holds the two together
Tada! You have your first whoopie pie
Makes roughly 18-20 individual sized whoopie pies
There ya have it folks! These are a huge hit with everyone! My husband loves them and asks for them often, texting me from work to make a batch before he gets home ha. They were also a huge hit with friends at our party, the gluten free and dairy free people were especially thrilled there was something safe for them to enjoy. In fact, I only told the people I knew had specific allergies that these desserts were safe for them, I told no one else and I assume as much that no one else even thought to question these whoopie pies “real-ness.” Most gluten free desserts really are great! In fact I prefer gluten free chocolate chip cookies over “normal” ones any day! Whether eating gluten free or diary free is a requirement for your dietary needs, I suggest you give these a try, they really are that good!
As usual, let me know if you do try them! I love hearing how you like these recipes <3